Speedfil A2 Review

I don’t love the idea of writing negative reviews, BUT I appreciate honest better reviews of products so that I could be a more informed buyer.  This is not a sponsored post; I purchased these products myself. 

I’ve road biked for a long time, using my standard two bottle cages on my bike frame (one in the jersey back pocket if I really needed it), and stopping when I was out of water as most cyclists do.  Once I switched to a tri bike, I was overwhelmed by all the hydration options and devices.  I thought I wanted a straw, to make sure I stayed hydrated, so I purchased the Speedfil A2 so I didn’t have to have to have a big reservoir and straw running all over my bike frame.  I also purchased an X-lab Turbo Wing and some Gorilla cages to hang behind my seat – I am really happy with and highly recommend these by the way!   

DSCN0001

I got the Speefil Z4 cage and X-lab Torpedo mount so that I could mount my Garmin 500 where I could see it.  The torpedo mount might not be necessary; you could use zip-ties, but I like being able to take it on and off if needed for trainer rides and maintenance.

DSCN0006

I used the Speedfil A2 for around 4-6 months, including my last half ironman race, and I really wanted it to work for me, but after much frustration I’ve switched to using just regular bottles on a front cage mount.  The Speedfil A2 was too over-designed, had multiple failure points (poor engineering), and was time-consuming to use and clean. 

Capture1

Multiple Design Issues on the Speedfil A2:

  1. Leak Point at Straw Gasket: There is a rubber gasket the straw travels through to connect to the main bottle.  After time, this leaks. 
  2. Leak Point at Bottle Threading: The threading on the bottle is always in a horizontal position.  After time and multiple washes, this also leaked on me.  We tried using teflon tape, but I still got sticky drink mix ALL over my bike once the threads weren’t sealing. 
  3. Faulty Bite Valve: The mouth piece on the straw went missing after my half ironman – just gone.  It must have fallen out, so I had to buy another one; $10 down the drain.  When I put the other one on, it was very hard to open and close.  I had to pull so hard to open it, the whole valve would come off the straw. 
  4. Straw Instructions / Durability: When I first set up the Speedfil, I followed the instructions and cut the straw to the length they had in the drawing, just above the insulation material.  I quickly realized this was way too short for me, so I contacted Speedfil.  They only directed me to buy replacement tubing, and noted that tubing should be replaced after a season anyway.  Another part I have to replace often?  You’ll also notice there is a janky white wire (from a hanger) I had to put in the insulation and around the top of the bottle to keep the straw upright and not flopping down on my wrist.  I heard others had received insulation with a wire built in, so I tried to contact Speedfil about this, but received no response.

In addition, I found this product time-consuming to clean and use.  The cleaning required taking the whole thing apart, and using straw cleaners to get the sticky drink mix out – which you will likely have unless you only drink water.  Plus, you have to have this clean all the time if it your sole bottle for bike rides and it is a weird shape to store.

Now I’m still using the Speedfil Z4 cage to mount my regular bike bottles in between my aero bars (I much prefer an X-lab torpedo carbon cage but there is no place for my Garmin).  I just rotate the bottles around and put whatever one I’m using in the front.  No messy refills, and I found out I really don’t need a straw to remind me to drink.   And I have tons of standard bottles that can be washed easily and are interchangeable.  What’s your hydration set up?  I think mine is set for ironman now!  Related: IowaTriBob just did a review of the Xlab Torpedo 400 which is a similar horizontal bottle set up like the Speedfil A2.

IMG_0949

Bottles & snacks ready for my long weekday rides – so easy!

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Speedfil A2 Review

  1. Very good review and pretty much mirror’s the experience I had with the XLAB Torpedo 400 system. I’m also 100% with you, I just hate writing a negative review (just doesn’t feel quite right, but if it helps someone else then its worth it).

    I’ve had really good success so far with the Speefil Standard although I would have to agree that it’s still a hassle to have to clean and the straw and bite valve do need to be replaced often.

    1. Thanks! Yeah, I just found I don’t want to mess with a specific system when I have so many cycling bottles that are easier to use anyway 🙂 Plus, I can’t stand sticky drinks dripping on me & my bike!!

  2. Pleased that others are struggling with the Speedfill. Me and my bike are just a sticky mess after a ride so my thoughts are now confirmed im just going to place a regular bottle on my aeros from now on. £50 down the drain unfortunately!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s